Best Renters Insurance New York / Compare Costs & Coverage In NY

New York Renters Insurance, Renters Insurance New York, Renters Insurance In New York, NY Renters Insurance, Renters Insurance NY

Best Renters Insurance New York

Advertiser Disclosure:  Our content is free because we are supported by advertisers.  If you click on links in this post, we may earn a commission.

Location is the #1 factor in determining the cost of your renter’s insurance

So it makes a lot of sense for you to search Best Renters Insurance New York if you need a policy. 

However, a New York Renters Insurance search can take a lot of time and leave you frustrated with unanswered questions. 

But, it doesn’t have to be that way. 

Finding cheap NY Renters Insurance can be a simple process that can be completed online today in just a few minutes. 

We’ll review everything you need to know about the cost and coverage's and where to get the best Renters Insurance in New York online.

2021 New York Renters Insurance Review

Finding affordable and high-quality renters insurance in New York shouldn’t be a hassle. Whether you’ve snatched a beautiful SoHo apartment or are renting a cottage-style home in upstate NY, ensuring that you protect your living space is vital. You don’t want to get caught paying damages if something goes wrong. 

There are numerous agencies offering renters insurance in New York at various price points. Your location, deductible, coverage, and add-ons all determine how much you’ll be paying. The following reviews outline the best and worst parts of each insurance agency so you can find the best and most affordable New York renters insurance for you. 

What Factors Determine a New York Renters Insurance Rate? 

Even though renters insurance isn’t a requirement to be a tenant in NY state, it’s an essential item to protect you, your living space, and even your belongings. When looking at rates, these are the following factors that will determine how much you pay: 


New York has numerous geographic locations with different costs of living. A Manhattan studio apartment’s renters insurance will have a much different price than a small house in the Adirondacks. 


How much can you afford to pay out of pocket before your claim coverage begins? Whatever deductible you choose will directly affect your New York renters insurance premium. A lower deductible will get you a higher premium, while a higher deductible will come with a lower premium. 

Studenomics Official Logo

Renters Insurance Starting at $5/month

No brokers, no paperwork, get a policy in seconds.  Zero Hassle, zero paperwork, zero worry. Join now!  Starting at $5/month.

It's free to apply!

Can A Landlord In New York Require Renters Insurance? 

It doesn’t matter if you live in New York, Buffalo, or Rochester, landlords can be a pain. 

A question we are often asked by soon to be tenants, is, ‘Can a landlord in New York require renters insurance?’

The simple answer is Yes. 

If NY renters insurance is included as a requirement in your lease, you must comply with those terms and buy rental coverage. 

This isn’t necessarily a NY thing because the answer to, ‘Is renters insurance required in New York?’ It is the exact opposite. 

No, New York does not require renters insurance, but with 24% of people in New York renting, it makes a lot of sense to protect your self and your stuff. 

A good place to start would be by determining What Is Renters Insurance And Why Do I Need It.

FREE Renters Insurance Quotes - NY - Cities

Location is the biggest factor in determining the cost of your renters insurance.  You can save money by getting a quote from an insurance company near you. 

Select Your City Below

What Is The Best Renters Insurance In New York?

It is estimated that the State of New York has over 4,605,124 renters, and every one of them should be looking for the best renters insurance in NY

NY has the best renters insurance options offered by multiple, well known, and respected insurance companies. 

It doesn’t matter if you are in New York or Buffalo to get the best NY renters insurance you will want to get the right coverage.

Several factors go into finding the best renters insurance in New York that will affect your policy. 

Your past insurance history, desired coverage amounts, the location of the rental, and this one may come as a bit of a surprise, but your credit score may also be considered.

You can learn more about the process in our article, How To Get Renters Insurance

Which Companies Offer Renters Insurance In New York?

What Does Renters Insurance Cover In New York

Many NY residents in Yonkers and Syracuse mistakenly believe that their Landlord’s insurance protects their personal items. 

This is not the case and is the reason you need to know, ‘What does renters insurance cover in New York.’

NY Renters Insurance covers personal loss due to fire, theft, or vandalism. 

A New York Renters Insurance policy will also cover your liability if a guest is injured on-premises or you damage the Landlord’s property. 

A Renters Insurance New York policy does not cover your personal possessions that may break by accident or normal wear or tear. 

Get a much more complete answer to in our article,  What Does Renters Insurance Cover.

Coverage Type

What It Should Cover...

Personal Property

This coverage is for your personal stuff, clothes, electronics, furniture, etc. Should cover up to policy limits.


This will cover you if you accidentally damage your Landlords property or a guest is injured and it is your fault.

Additional Living Expenses

If your place is damaged so bad you can't stay, you will be reimbursed for things like hotel bills.

Recommended Amount Of Renters Insurance In New York?

It is difficult to recommend the amount of New York renters insurance you may need.

This is because the factors that go into deciding on your coverage amounts are particular to each individual. 

Location plays a significant factor in the recommended amount of renters insurance in New York

This is because if you live in New York, Buffalo, or Rochester, you may need more or less based on the value of the property you are renting. 

The bottom line is you should probably buy as much insurance as you can comfortably afford based on the value of your personal possessions. 

We get a lot more in-depth in helping you make this decision in our article How Much Renters Insurance Do I Need.

How Much Is Renters Insurance In New York

The cost of renters insurance in NY depends primarily on your coverage's and the location of your rental. 

Answering the question of, ‘How much is renters insurance in New York’ would be difficult without knowing your personal situation and preferences. 

However, renters insurance New York costs on an average annual basis of $194.00

The average cost of renters insurance in New York monthly is $16.17, which is very affordable. 

Keep in mind to determine how much is renters insurance in NY your rental location could make these average costs much higher or lower.

Studenomics Official Logo

Renters Insurance Starting at $5/month

No brokers, no paperwork, get a policy in seconds.  Zero Hassle, zero paperwork, zero worry. Join now!  Starting at $5/month.

It's free to apply!

Cheapest Renters Insurance NY

It would help if you didn’t live in places like New York, Buffalo, and Syracuse to get the cheapest renters insurance in New York

Location plays a huge role if you want to get cheap renters insurance NY

That means places like Rochester and Yonkers may be cheaper because the property values should be less. 

Two other factors will help you get the cheap renter’s insurance New York, which includes your insurance claim history and your credit score. 

If you are living in a relatively cheap property with no rental claims and a good credit score, expect the cheapest renters insurance in NY.

Renters Insurance By State

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *